Argyle have four players in the side; Romain Larrieu, Graham Coughlan, Paul Wooton and David Friio.
For Mansfield Town, Lee Williamson and Chris Greenacre were voted in.
Fat Luton Town manager Joe Kinnear however has been left with egg on his face after he last week threw a benny because he thought no-one from his team were in, despite laying second in the table.
The useless get now has to backtrack after Matthew Taylor was named in last nights Awards Ceremony.
The side in full: Romain Larrieu (Plymouth Argyle), Michael Duff (Cheltenham Town), Paul Wotton (Plymouth Argyle), Graham Coughlan (Plymouth Argyle), Matthew Taylor (Luton Town) Peter Beagrie (Scunthorpe United), David Friio (Plymouth Argyle), Lee Hodges (Scunthorpe United), Lee Williamson (Mansfield Town), Chris Greenacre (Mansfield Town), Nathan Ellington (Bristol Rovers).