Togwell won the main award, the Ernie Storey Memorial Trophy, collecting the most votes from Scunthorpe United supporters.
Michael O'Connor, who finished the season top scorer with nine goals, scooped up five of the six left on offer.
There was also an award for January signing Michael Nelson, who was presented the accolade by the Official supporters club, who also presented Ashley Palmer, the young centre back, the junior award.
The Irish Iron decided against awarding the annual accolade, deciding it would be more appropriate to invest the money into player sponsorship next season.
Winterton Iron Player of the Year - Michael O'Connor
Scunthorpe United Disabled Supporters' Club John Rees Player of the Year Home - Sam Togwell
Scunthorpe United Disabled Supporters' Club Gerry Hewitt Player of the Year Away - Michael O'Connor
Official Supporters' Club Junior Player of the Year - Ashley Palmer
Official Supporters' Club Junior Supporters' Player of the Year -Michael O'Connor
Official Supporters' Club Away Travel Player of the Year - Michael O'Connor
Official Supporters' Club Iron Bar Player of the Year - Sam Togwell
Official Supporters' Club Player of the Year - Michael Nelson
Scunthorpe Telegraph Readers' Choice Player of the Year - Michael O'Connor
Ernie Storey Memorial Trophy - Sam Togwell